Facing a Forced Return to Office? Here's How to Protect Your Remote Job

Jake’s (Few) Legal Options

Jake’s company has informed employees that failure to comply with the return-to-office (RTO) mandate by next year will result in termination. While this may seem unfair or even discriminatory, it is generally legal in the U.S. Most states operate under at-will employment laws, allowing employers to terminate employees for any legal reason without notice. This also permits companies to update employment terms unilaterally, as happened to Jake.

In rare cases, RTO mandates could be considered harassment or discrimination, such as when an employee has a disclosed disability requiring remote work accommodation. However, without such circumstances, employers are typically within their rights to demand office work, even if the role was initially remote.

Jake's only potential legal recourse is if his employment contract explicitly states the position is remote and includes a severance provision for termination under these conditions. Since the mandate is company-wide, this is unlikely, but he should review his contract carefully. For those considering remote jobs, negotiating such a clause upfront can provide future protection.

What Can Jake Do?

Employers in the U.S. have broad discretion to set workplace policies, including work location. Jake's company can legally fire him and hire someone willing to work on-site.

Jake can attempt to negotiate with his boss and HR, emphasizing that he was hired as a fully remote worker from another state and has a proven track record of high productivity. He can highlight his specialized role and the lack of ready replacements, potentially securing a compromise like hybrid work with occasional office visits. If successful, he should update his contract to safeguard against future policy changes.

Some companies use RTO mandates to reduce headcount without formal layoffs, minimizing severance costs. While others offer incentives like childcare or commuting coverage, Jake should assess if his employer is open to exceptions.

Voluntary Attrition

Quitting in response to RTO might seem like a protest, but it could align with the company's goal of voluntary attrition to cut costs and avoid layoff publicity.

If in Jake's position, it's advisable to stay in the role while preparing for potential unemployment, such as by job hunting. If laid off, Jake may qualify for unemployment insurance; quitting would make him ineligible.

Protecting Your Finances

As more companies shift to hybrid or in-office work, remote workers should keep employment options open. Job turnover is common, with a median tenure of 3.9 years in 2024, so always be ready for change.

To stay financially prepared:

• Save six months of expenses in an emergency fund for job searches.
• Avoid high-debt investments like mortgages in unstable job markets.
• Stay as debt-free as possible to preserve savings.
• Keep skills current through training, ideally employer-funded.
• Maintain updated LinkedIn, portfolios, and resumes.
• Network regularly and stay in touch with recruiters.

Article Sources

At Moneywise, we ensure content accuracy with vetted sources like government data and expert interviews. For details, see our editorial ethics.

[1]. Business Insider: "The list of major companies requiring employees to return to the office" [2]. Halunen Law: "Back to work: can your employer force you to return to the office?" [3]. upcounsel: "What States Are Not At Will Employment & Key Exceptions" [4]. Fortune: "Bosses admit they’re using return-to-office mandates to trim down teams" [5]. Social Security: "Unemployment insurance"